Comments on: Jinnah’s dream and the reality

By: Naeem

Naeem — Thu, 01 Jan 1970 00:00:00 +0000

Surinder, we take so much interest in each others nation because behind all the hostility we are one people. I do not know why but my heart swells with pride when I see India achieve great things although I know I am a Pakistani. similarly I feel as disappointed as nay Indian when India looses a game of cricket against Australia or UK. Perhaps behind all this hostility we secrely admire each other becuase we know that we were one once upon a time. We both can move on but I doubt we will ever be able to forget our natural ties with each other. And by the way , this not how I feel about our other neighbours, Iran, Russia, China, etc.

By: NASAH (USA)

NASAH (USA) — Thu, 01 Jan 1970 00:00:00 +0000

The way the things are ‘progressing’ in Pakistan since its inception — Jinnah’s dream will remain a dream for the foreseeable future.

By: Mudassir baloch

Mudassir baloch — Thu, 01 Jan 1970 00:00:00 +0000

When i came across the view of people talking about jinnah,s dream, it give the impression that our nation is standing where jinnah had left it. we are not only progressing in terms of material progress but also not progressing in terms of mental uplift.Jinnah gave his dream according to his common sense which is based on the available knowledge at that time.now the time has changed and also the requirements of state has also changed. i believe those who talk about jinnah,s dream do not want to move forfard rather drag the country to the pas.

By: Nabarun Dey

Nabarun Dey — Thu, 01 Jan 1970 00:00:00 +0000

Jinnah created Pakistan but he was half Muslim. I suggest, keep the religion at bay and Pakistan will Prosper.

By: U Gupta

U Gupta — Thu, 01 Jan 1970 00:00:00 +0000

Mr. Jinnah wanted to become Governor General of India and may be Prime Minister and Nehru did not permit him. It was typical political fight. Jinnah had nothing to do with Muslims or Hindus. He was a great lawyer who made lot of money and enjoyed good life.

All other discussions is of no use.

By: Dr Rajesh Gupta

Dr Rajesh Gupta — Thu, 01 Jan 1970 00:00:00 +0000

This is an interesting article with equally interesting comments. This is the first time I see Indian and pakistanis not abusing each others religion on a forum. most of the comments are bit restraint and civilized and in good faith. Thats a very encouraging sign. Actually i presume whosoever is using internet and english is got to be educated. but i feel really sad when these so called educated people starts abusing each other and give comments which are shameful, esp as it is not expected from civilzed society. I hope that good sense will prevail, and people will come forward . We can develop peacefully toghether and prosper or we can fight till eternity and perish. Choice is ours. Counter the communal forces on both sides and come out triumphant. May god bless both these country.

By: atif javed

atif javed — Thu, 01 Jan 1970 00:00:00 +0000

I am surprised to read this article that it has been published without asking the writer to substantiate the substance.
For example, he talked of the forced conversions, has he taken into account the religious conversions
taking place over the globe, even in USA and for that matter India where Islam is the fastest growing
religion. Are the converters from Christianity and Hinduism in USA and India forced too.

Who said that Quaid-e-Azam wanted a secular state. Quaid repeatedly said that Quran is the book
which would guide Pakistanis to determine the form of government. Yes talking of rights of
minorities, these have been amply explained in Islam and are not lesser then any other nation or for
that matter secular states.
Islam says don’t spread rumors without verification terming it a lie. Unfortunately to give a high blood pressure to the article, writer has just quoted gimmicks and rumors without any substantial proof. This is what I call JOURNALISM OF OPINION not the facts.

By: sharin

sharin — Thu, 01 Jan 1970 00:00:00 +0000

it’s ridiculous to blame a country for the people ills-what is required is that, everyone of us follow the basic good laws ,that Allah gave us, to maintain good relations with all humankind.Quid-e-Azam Mohammad Ali Jinnah Was a Great Man,liked and respected well by friends and foe alike(May Allah rest his soul in peace,Ameen)He did his part in this world,now it is our turn.

By: Human

Human — Thu, 01 Jan 1970 00:00:00 +0000

Education and exposure to the world outside the boundaries of Islam will help Pakistan.

You must be the change you want to see in the world – Gandhi

All the best Pakistan!

By: Sanjay

Sanjay — Thu, 01 Jan 1970 00:00:00 +0000

i disagree if jinnah made this nation for islam than he can ask all hindu to get out of pak he never think islam practice in danger but their right and voice can remain unheard due to majority of hindus and he also want to show to india that how good the how good the minority should be treated but their fall in all three front islam accept the sunni is in danger in pak second democracy is in pressur of army and judicary and third minority suffering while in india contary to him flowring mistake is what pak people still don’t know what he want and army and argument is going on